Keiran Gill I think.

1. Where did I say we should have a rule that if a player has a stinker and doesn’t improve we should move them on? YOU not me literally just made that up and passed it off as something I said.  Why do that???


2. With the context of me saying I would like Atoni to show his good form consistently before I make up my mind fully. How has TJ and Max now been brought into it as they are proven SL players. We know they are capable at SL level already. It’s players who haven’t played SL or limited SL that need to prove in varying degrees their capability at this level. 


3. I haven’t passed comment on Atoni last year. We are talking about SL and I’ve already said that Atoni is playing well these first 2 games. I don’t know whether you’re saying that as if I had disagreed at some point when I have already said he’s playing well. 

Ok that's fair enough.
I guess I confused your confidence in Walmsley with you thinking he's good enough for a contract.


No need to be so offended. I asked a question and you answered it.
I'm OK with that.


I have confidence in Atoni. For me he's already done enough to talk contract extension.
In my opinion Walmsley hasn't yet, but these are only his first games in SL. He's got time

Not had the best day. Sorry, didn’t mean to be so uptight. 

I have growing confidence in Atoni too and I’ll support him. I certainly have more confidence in him after his first 2 games but I just want to see him perform as he has for a a few games more that’s all. If we are aiming top 6 then we need players who will perform consistently long term.


My opinions can change. For example, I wasn’t keen on Matty Russell at all but I’ve been impressed by him and think that he has a lot to offer this season. I wouldn’t be dissapointed to see either Russell or Walmsley line up as it stands. 


I don’t think Walmsley is good enough for SL and he’s shown up pretty well vs top 4 opposition but he will have to put in some very good performances to get a contract with a few young players snapping for a starting spot next season. I guess we’ll see how it plays out. 


I do like the look of Faatili and will be interesting to see him continue to improve. 

Agree Faatill is looking the real deal the more he plays ,the Question is who do we leave out of the 17 squad in the forwards when all fit Powell even said he is going to have to make some big decision about the team in a few week when players start returning. 

Agree Faatill is looking the real deal the more he plays ,the Question is who do we leave out of the 17 squad in the forwards when all fit Powell even said he is going to have to make some big decision about the team in a few week when players start returning.